Current:Home > ContactNorth Carolina court reverses contempt charge against potential juror who wouldn’t wear mask -AssetLink
North Carolina court reverses contempt charge against potential juror who wouldn’t wear mask
View
Date:2025-04-12 16:36:42
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — A North Carolina judge wrongly found a potential juror in criminal contempt for refusing to wear a mask in 2022 due to COVID-19, a state appeals court ruled Tuesday.
The three-judge Court of Appeals panel agreed unanimously to reverse the order against Gregory Hahn, saying in part that his actions didn’t interrupt court proceedings. Hahn had received a 24-hour jail sentence from Superior Court Judge Winston Gilchrist in October 2022. He asked that the state’s intermediate-level court hear his case.
The judge in 2022 declared that Hahn had been ordered three times to wear a mask. Gilchrist’s order also found that Hahn “willfully behaved in a contemptuous manner” and his conduct harmed the respect that the court’s authority was due.
According to Tuesday’s opinion, the Harnett County Courthouse at the time was under a mask directive — signed in part by Gilchrist — that said masks were optional in common areas and meeting rooms, but judges had discretion to require masks inside their courtrooms.
Hahn reported for jury duty and was directed to a jury assembly room. When a courthouse worker asked him there to wear a mask, he declined. He was removed from the room and taken to a courtroom where Gilchrist told him about the mask requirement in his courtroom where he’d be a potential juror and in the jury assembly room. Hahn responded that “with all due respect, I will not be wearing a mask, sir.” He was found in contempt after Gilchrist warned him about the potential punishments.
Writing the prevailing opinion, Court of Appeals Judge Michael Stading said the elements of criminal contempt weren’t present in this case. Hahn did not disrupt court, Stading wrote, pointing out that he was not a participant in ongoing proceedings in a courtroom and was respectful to Gilchrist.
The masking directive was also invalid because it came several months after state Supreme Court Chief Justice Paul Newby issued a statewide order revoking all pandemic emergency directives, including those giving discretion to local courts, according to Stading.
Even so, there is nothing sufficient to support findings that Hahn “could have known his discussion with the courthouse employee in the jury assembly room might directly interrupt proceedings or interfere with the court’s order or business,” Stading wrote. Judge April Wood agreed with Stading’s opinion. Judge Jefferson Griffin agreed with the outcome but wrote a separate opinion.
The state Supreme Court could now hear the cause if there are further appeals, but the justices aren’t required to do so.
veryGood! (1377)
Related
- Organizers cancel Taylor Swift concerts in Vienna over fears of an attack
- Federal courts move to restrict ‘judge shopping,’ which got attention after abortion medication case
- Best Box Hair Dyes to Try This Spring: Get the Hair Color You Want at Home
- Judge dismisses suit by Georgia slave descendants over technical errors. Lawyers vow to try again
- Video shows dog chewing cellphone battery pack, igniting fire in Oklahoma home
- Concorde supersonic jet will return to New York’s Intrepid Museum after seven-month facelift
- U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents roll out body cameras to agents in five cities
- Yankees ace Gerrit Cole out until at least May, will undergo more elbow exams
- North Carolina trustees approve Bill Belichick’s deal ahead of introductory news conference
- Officers kill armed man outside of Las Vegas-area complex before finding 3 slain women inside
Ranking
- Whoopi Goldberg is delightfully vile as Miss Hannigan in ‘Annie’ stage return
- How Chinese is TikTok? US lawmakers see it as China’s tool, even as it distances itself from Beijing
- The Excerpt podcast: Climate change is making fungi a much bigger threat
- Oklahoma teen Nex Benedict’s cause of death revealed in autopsy report
- The 'Rebel Ridge' trailer is here: Get an exclusive first look at Netflix movie
- The 8 Best Luxury Pillows That Are Editor-Approved and Actually Worth the Investment
- Ukrainian ministers ‘optimistic’ about securing U.S. aid, call for repossession of Russian assets
- Checking In With Justin Chambers, Patrick Dempsey and More Departed Grey's Anatomy Doctors
Recommendation
Federal court filings allege official committed perjury in lawsuit tied to Louisiana grain terminal
Scott Peterson's lawyers ask for new DNA test in push to overturn Laci Peterson conviction
C.J. Gardner-Johnson apologizes to Eagles fans for 'obnoxious' comment following reunion
Federal judge finds Flint, Michigan, in contempt over lead water pipe crisis
US auto safety agency seeks information from Tesla on fatal Cybertruck crash and fire in Texas
Man spent years trying to create giant hybrid sheep to be sold and hunted as trophies, federal prosecutors say
'1 in 400 million': Rare cow with two heads, four eyes born at a farm in Louisiana
HIV prevention drugs known as PrEP are highly effective, but many at risk don't know about them