Current:Home > ContactNorth Carolina court reverses contempt charge against potential juror who wouldn’t wear mask -AssetLink
North Carolina court reverses contempt charge against potential juror who wouldn’t wear mask
View
Date:2025-04-18 18:47:01
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — A North Carolina judge wrongly found a potential juror in criminal contempt for refusing to wear a mask in 2022 due to COVID-19, a state appeals court ruled Tuesday.
The three-judge Court of Appeals panel agreed unanimously to reverse the order against Gregory Hahn, saying in part that his actions didn’t interrupt court proceedings. Hahn had received a 24-hour jail sentence from Superior Court Judge Winston Gilchrist in October 2022. He asked that the state’s intermediate-level court hear his case.
The judge in 2022 declared that Hahn had been ordered three times to wear a mask. Gilchrist’s order also found that Hahn “willfully behaved in a contemptuous manner” and his conduct harmed the respect that the court’s authority was due.
According to Tuesday’s opinion, the Harnett County Courthouse at the time was under a mask directive — signed in part by Gilchrist — that said masks were optional in common areas and meeting rooms, but judges had discretion to require masks inside their courtrooms.
Hahn reported for jury duty and was directed to a jury assembly room. When a courthouse worker asked him there to wear a mask, he declined. He was removed from the room and taken to a courtroom where Gilchrist told him about the mask requirement in his courtroom where he’d be a potential juror and in the jury assembly room. Hahn responded that “with all due respect, I will not be wearing a mask, sir.” He was found in contempt after Gilchrist warned him about the potential punishments.
Writing the prevailing opinion, Court of Appeals Judge Michael Stading said the elements of criminal contempt weren’t present in this case. Hahn did not disrupt court, Stading wrote, pointing out that he was not a participant in ongoing proceedings in a courtroom and was respectful to Gilchrist.
The masking directive was also invalid because it came several months after state Supreme Court Chief Justice Paul Newby issued a statewide order revoking all pandemic emergency directives, including those giving discretion to local courts, according to Stading.
Even so, there is nothing sufficient to support findings that Hahn “could have known his discussion with the courthouse employee in the jury assembly room might directly interrupt proceedings or interfere with the court’s order or business,” Stading wrote. Judge April Wood agreed with Stading’s opinion. Judge Jefferson Griffin agreed with the outcome but wrote a separate opinion.
The state Supreme Court could now hear the cause if there are further appeals, but the justices aren’t required to do so.
veryGood! (9881)
Related
- Sonya Massey's father decries possible release of former deputy charged with her death
- St. Louis man sentenced to 10 years for causing crash that killed 4 people and injured 4 others
- Gay rights advocates in Kentucky say expansion to religious freedom law would hurt LGBTQ+ safeguards
- We Found the Gold Wine Glasses That Love Is Blind Fans Can’t Stop Talking About
- A Georgia governor’s latest work after politics: a children’s book on his cats ‘Veto’ and ‘Bill’
- Hilary Swank recalls the real-life 'Ordinary Angels' that helped her to Hollywood stardom
- Your Summer Tan Is Here: Dolce Glow's Founder on How to Get the Perfect Celeb-Loved Bronze at Home
- 2 climbers are dead and another is missing on Pico de Orizaba, Mexico's highest mountain
- Connie Chiume, Black Panther Actress, Dead at 72: Lupita Nyong'o and More Pay Tribute
- Dashiell Soren-Founder of Alpha Elite Capital (AEC) Business Management
Ranking
- Blake Lively’s Inner Circle Shares Rare Insight on Her Life as a Mom to 4 Kids
- Wendy Williams' Medical Diagnosis: Explaining Primary Progressive Aphasia and Frontotemporal Dementia
- Angelica Ross commends Issa Rae's 'resilience' in Hollywood amid the racial wealth gap
- Alabama lawmakers move to protect IVF treatment
- Jamaica's Kishane Thompson more motivated after thrilling 100m finish against Noah Lyles
- Talk show host Wendy Williams diagnosed with frontotemporal dementia and aphasia
- Texas AG Ken Paxton sues Catholic migrant aid organization for alleged 'human smuggling'
- Remakes take over Nintendo Direct: Epic Mickey and Mother 3, plus Star Wars and more
Recommendation
US appeals court rejects Nasdaq’s diversity rules for company boards
Cezanne seascape mural discovered at artist's childhood home
A Mississippi university pauses its effort to remove ‘Women’ from its name
What is the hottest pepper in the world? Pepper X, Carolina Reaper ranked on the spice scale
Federal court filings allege official committed perjury in lawsuit tied to Louisiana grain terminal
Ex-FBI source accused of lying about Bidens and having Russian contacts is returned to US custody
Private lunar lander is closing in on the first US touchdown on the moon in a half-century
Get Rid of Redness in an Instant, Frizzy Hair in 60 Seconds & More With My Favorite New Beauty Launches